Debates struktūra

Tā kā mums priekšā Tallina turnīrs, un rīt, ir sesija angliski, nolēmu iepostost blogā ļoti vienkāršu paraugu, kādai jāizskatās katra runātāja struktūrai, pamatā viss jau zināms, bet ir arī daži aspekti, kas varbūt nav tik zināmi - īsāk sakot atkārtošana zināšanu māte, un uzlabot struktūru jau var vienmēr :)

WORLDS FORMAT SPEECH GUIDE
Alfred Snider, University of Vermont
Also thanks to Colm Flynn
All speeches are seven minutes long. Four two-person teams. Each speaker
should take two points of information from opponents during the speech. Teams
are ranked 1-4. Topics (or motions) debated come from current events and
controversies. 15-30 minutes given for preparation before the debate begins.
GOVERNMENT OPPOSITION
1ST GOVT TEAM, 1ST SPEAKER
Introduction about the motion
Definition of important terms (if needed)
Plan/model (if needed)
Preview the arguments of 1st Govt team
Argument #1 – lots of explanation and
examples
Argument #2 – same
Conclusion
1st OPP TEAM, 1ST SPEAKER
Introduction about the motion
Argue definitions (if it is a must)
Refute both Govt arguments
Preview arguments of 1st Opp team
Argument #1 – lots of explanation and
examples
Argument #2 – same
Conclusion
1st GOVT TEAM, 2ND SPEAKER
Introduction
Refute developed Opp arguments
Rebuild & defend Govt original case
Argument #3– lots of explanation and
examples
Conclusion
1ST OPP TEAM, 2ND SPEAKER
Introduction
Refute new Govt Argument completely
Continue attack on other Govt args
Defend partners Arguments
Present additional Argument of 1st Govt
Conclusion
2ND GOVT TEAM, 1ST SPEAKER
Introduction
Refute new Opp Argument completely
Present major new Govt Argument (or two)
Extend best points of 1st Govt team
Conclusion
2ND OPP TEAM, 1ST SPEAKER
Introduction
Refute major new Govt argument completely
Present major new Opp Argument (or two)
Extend best points by 1st Opp team
Conclusion
2ND GOVT TEAM, 2ND SPEAKER
THE GOVT WHIP SPEECH
Introduction
Refute major new Opp Argument (or two)
completely
Expand major new Govt argument
Summarize whole Debate
Weigh importance of different issues
May restructure the debate in summarizing
Conclusion
2ND OPP TEAM, 2ND SPEAKER
THE OPP WHIP SPEECH
Introduction
Extend best attacks against Govt
Extend best arguments by Opp while taking
care not to introduce new lines of
argumentation
Summarize whole Debate
Weigh importance of different issues
May restructure the debate in summarizing
Conclusion